I’ve watched a lot of slasher movies. I’ve seen Jason and Freddy and Michael punish teenagers for having sex, drinking alcohol, smoking marijuana and generally enjoying themselves a little too much. I’ve watched masked psychopaths return from the dead, survive impossible injuries and pursue their victims with a determination that would be admirable if it weren’t so deeply antisocial.
So when I sat down to watch In a Violent Nature (2024), I thought I was getting another supernatural killer stalking a group of young people through the woods, dispatching them in increasingly creative and anatomically improbable ways. And that’s exactly what it is, on the surface.
But something has been overlooked in much of the discussion surrounding it. Because while everyone seems fascinated by its unusual perspective, its minimalist approach to filmmaking and that spectacularly gruesome yoga scene, I think there’s a much more interesting interpretation hiding in plain sight, and a big hint is in the title. What if In a Violent Nature is about nature itself?
****
What everyone thinks the movie is about
When In a Violent Nature premiered at Sundance in 2024, critics were fascinated by its unconventional approach to the slasher genre. Rather than following a group of attractive young people as they’re gradually picked off by a masked murderer, the film follows the murderer himself. We spend much of its 94 minute runtime trudging through the Canadian wilderness behind Johnny, a Voorhees-inspired undead killer with a fondness for lumberjack equipment and a remarkably impressive step count.
The result has been described as an ambient slasher, an arthouse slasher, and even a cross between Friday the 13th and a nature documentary. Critics have praised the film’s patient pacing, minimalist sound design and willingness to make us spend an extraordinary amount of time watching a man walk through trees. Reviewers interpret the movie as a deconstruction of the slasher genre, and focus on Johnny as the next tragic Jason Voorhees figure. Some reviewers note how the pacing and lack of sound make the brutality seem banal and inevitable.
Writer-director Chris Nash has been surprisingly modest about his innovation. In an interview with TIME, he rejected the suggestion that he’d reinvented the slasher genre. In his view, he’d simply moved the camera to a different position. The familiar ingredients remain: an unstoppable killer, disposable victims, increasingly inventive murders and a final girl. The audience just watches everything from the other side of the machete.
Nash has also cited the influence of filmmakers such as Gus Van Sant and Terrence Malick, whose work often favours observation, atmosphere and contemplative pacing over conventional storytelling. The long stretches of walking aren’t merely padding between murders. They’re an attempt to make us experience the killer’s world without the usual cinematic manipulation of dramatic music, frantic editing and carefully timed jump scares.
But I think there’s another way of interpreting the movie. One that makes its unusual cinematography, its setting, its murders and even its seemingly anticlimactic ending part of the same argument.
And it begins with taking the title literally.
Nature is a violent place
Most of us have a rather romanticised relationship with nature. We enjoy bushwalking, camping, listening to birdsong and escaping the noise of civilisation. We admire the beauty of forests, the tranquillity of lakes and the majesty of wildlife. We might even put on recordings of rainforests or birdsong to help us relax.
But nature is also a place of extraordinary violence. Animals kill other animals to survive. Predators stalk their prey, parasites consume their hosts, and territorial disputes can end in death. Nature doesn’t recognise human concepts of justice, fairness or proportionality. A predator doesn’t consider whether its victim deserves to die.
This is what I think the movie is really trying to say.
Consider Jason Voorhees or Michael Myers. Although their motivations vary considerably between films, there’s a long tradition of interpreting slasher movies as morality tales. Teenagers who drink, take drugs or have premarital sex are frequently the first to die, while the comparatively virtuous final girl survives. The killer becomes a kind of grotesque moral enforcer, punishing people for transgressing society’s rules.
Johnny doesn’t appear particularly interested in morality. He doesn’t care whether his victims have been drinking, having sex or behaving irresponsibly. He has one objective: retrieve his mother’s stolen necklace. Anyone who interferes with that objective is killed.
Watch how he moves through the forest. He doesn’t charge around wildly or announce his presence with theatrical gestures. He walks slowly and deliberately, apparently unconcerned about how long his journey might take. When he encounters a potential victim, he often stops and observes, waiting for the opportunity to strike. Like a predator, he conserves his energy until the moment of attack. He strikes suddenly to incapacitate his prey, then takes his time finishing the job. There is no negotiation, no warning and no apparent consideration of the suffering he’s inflicting.
Johnny isn’t behaving like a human being who has decided to commit murder. He’s behaving like an animal following an instinct.
And if we accept that interpretation, something interesting happens to the entire movie. Johnny stops being a monster who happens to live in the forest and becomes the violence of the forest, given human form.
****
The forest fights back
The setting of In a Violent Nature is important. This isn’t a suburban neighbourhood, an abandoned hospital or a summer camp with a suspiciously high mortality rate. The film takes place almost entirely in a remote forest, and the landscape feels as much like a character as Johnny himself.
The movie was filmed in the forests of northern Ontario, particularly the Algoma District near Sault Ste. Marie. Nash has spoken about the importance of getting the location right, even reshooting much of the film after deciding that the original woodland setting didn’t have the atmosphere he wanted. The towering pines and evergreens weren’t merely a backdrop. They were essential to the movie’s identity.
And the film wastes little time establishing humanity’s uneasy relationship with this environment.
Among the first things Johnny encounters after emerging from the ground are animal traps and a dead animal – it might be a fox, or a coyote. It’s a creature of nature that has been violently trapped and left to die an agonising death. Shortly afterwards, he overhears a park ranger confronting a local trapper about his activities in a protected area. The trapper is then stalked and killed by Johnny. This is significant because Johnny has only awakened after someone removed the necklace that had kept him dormant. The person who actually takes the necklace is one of the visiting campers, but the early encounter with the trapper establishes a broader pattern: people enter the forest, take what they want, and assume there will be no consequences.
We later learn the story of Johnny’s death from campfire tales told by one of the campers. As a boy, he was killed in an incident involving a group of loggers, and his father subsequently died while seeking answers. Johnny’s vengeance culminated in a massacre called the White Pine Slaughter. Once again, the origin story is a tale of how violence comes to people associated with the exploitation of the forest.
Of course, we shouldn’t pretend that every person Johnny kills is guilty of an environmental offence. The campers are hardly engaged in industrial-scale deforestation, and some of his victims are simply unfortunate enough to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. But that’s precisely what makes the interpretation interesting. Nature doesn’t distinguish between the innocent and the guilty. It doesn’t punish people because they’ve violated an ethical principle. It responds to disturbance, sometimes with devastating consequences.
Johnny isn’t an environmental activist. He’s something much more frightening: a force that cannot be reasoned with, persuaded or made to care.
Born from the earth
One of the film’s most striking images comes almost immediately after the opening credits. Johnny’s decomposing body emerges from beneath the forest floor, clawing its way through the soil and vegetation.It’s an image we’ve seen countless times in zombie movies, but here it takes on a different significance. Johnny doesn’t emerge from a coffin in a cemetery or a laboratory where something has gone horribly wrong. He rises directly from the earth, as though the forest itself has given birth to him.
There’s an interesting visual detail in the opening shot. The camera looks through an empty picture frame, overgrown with moss, which frames the trees beyond it. Later, we see the frame from the opposite side, with Johnny positioned within it as he begins his journey. It’s almost as though the film is inviting us to reconsider what belongs in the picture. Initially, we see the forest as a landscape to be admired. Later, the same frame contains the violence that inhabits it.
Mother Nature has some interesting choice of weapons
There’s a wonderful irony in Johnny’s choice of weapons.
Throughout the film, he dispatches his victims using tools used to cut, manipulate or process wood. Among his weapons are an axe, a log peavey, a hacksaw and a log splitter. These are tools designed to give humans power over their environment. We use them to fell trees, move timber, split logs and transform natural resources into products we can consume. Johnny turns them against us. If you’re opposed to deforestation, there’s a certain poetic satisfaction in watching the forest reclaim its tools.
The most memorable example is undoubtedly the infamous yoga scene, in which Johnny uses a log peavey to perform an act of anatomical rearrangement that I sincerely hope never becomes part of anyone’s morning stretching routine.
The log splitter is an even more literal example. A machine designed to tear wood apart becomes an instrument for tearing a person apart. The technology that ordinarily demonstrates humanity’s mastery over nature becomes the means of our destruction.
I’m not suggesting that In a Violent Nature an environmental protest film. But the recurring use of forestry equipment, combined with the film’s setting and backstory as well as that final dialogue, creates an interpretation that’s difficult to ignore. Humanity has developed increasingly sophisticated ways of cutting nature into manageable pieces… with In a Violent Nature, nature returns the favour.
The sound of silence (and a lot of birds)
Perhaps the most effective way In a Violent Nature establishes its relationship with the natural world is through its sound design.
There is no musical score. No ominous strings warning us that Johnny is approaching, no sudden orchestral stabs when he attacks, and no dramatic crescendo to accompany the film’s most gruesome moments. Instead, we’re treated to the ambient sounds of the forest: birds chirping, insects buzzing, leaves rustling and the occasional crunch of Johnny’s boots against the ground. It’s the sort of soundtrack you might expect from a relaxation video on YouTube, except that every so often someone gets their head ripped off.
The absence of music fundamentally changes the way we experience the violence. In a conventional slasher movie, music tells us when to be afraid, when to anticipate danger and when to experience relief. Here, we’re given no such guidance. The forest continues making its ordinary noises, entirely indifferent to the atrocities taking place within it.
Consider the infamous yoga scene. As Johnny performs one of the most spectacularly grotesque murders in recent horror history, the soundtrack offers no musical accompaniment. The buzzing of insects continues, as though nothing particularly remarkable is happening.
And from nature’s perspective, perhaps nothing remarkable is happening. An animal has caught its prey. Flesh has been torn apart. Life has ended. The insects will eventually benefit from the remains.
The final chase sequence offers a particularly interesting contrast. As Kris desperately flees through the forest, the sounds of birds and other wildlife become almost overwhelming. The chirping, croaking and rustling create a cacophony that accompanies her panic.
These are the same noises I sometimes listen to when I’m trying to fall asleep. In In a Violent Nature, they become the soundtrack to a desperate struggle for survival.
It was an animal
If there’s one scene that brings my interpretation together, it’s the film’s ending.
After escaping Johnny, Kris is picked up by a passing motorist who notices that she’s injured and offers to help. The woman asks what happened, and Kris, struggling to explain the unimaginable violence she’s witnessed, tells her that it was an animal.
The driver then launches into a lengthy story about her brother’s experience with a bear attack. She describes a phenomenon sometimes called ‘henhouse syndrome’, in which a predator kills more animals than it needs to eat. A fox that enters a henhouse, for example, might kill numerous chickens despite being unable to consume them all. Also called ‘surplus killing’, this a behaviour observed in several predator species. Rather than killing only what is immediately necessary for survival, a predator may continue attacking when prey remains available and vulnerable.
The driver explains that the bear wasn’t necessarily acting out of hunger. It was simply behaving according to its nature. And then the film ends.
I think it’s the most important conversation in the entire film. The bear story seems to attempt to provide some explanation why Johnny’s violence is excessive and somewhat cruel. Excess is not exclusively a human characteristic. Nature contains creatures that kill far more than they need to survive.
Everyone is wrong. Except, of course, the director.
Interestingly, Chris Nash originally intended to call the film Sleeping Animal, and has described Johnny as a kind of reverse golem. Nash’s idea reverses that relationship: what if the earth itself created something to take revenge on humanity? That concept lends considerable weight to the interpretation of Johnny as an embodiment of nature’s violence, rather than merely another supernatural murderer wandering through the woods. In this Slant Magazine article, Nash states:
The original title of the film was pretty simple: Sleeping Animal. I wanted to treat the slasher as if it was in hibernation, an animal, part of nature, existing in his surroundings. So the role nature played was always very important for us. Originally, our concept of Johnny was that he was a reverse golem. Where the original golem tale is somebody building a tool of revenge out of the earth, we were thinking, “What if this one is the earth itself building a tool of revenge out of man?” Any naturalistic elements, and even just the decision to not use a traditional score for the film and just let nature speak throughout all the scenes, were all very conscious choices.
https://www.slantmagazine.com/film/chris-nash-interview-in-a-violent-nature/
I’d take that interpretation a little further. The illegal trapping, the history of logging, the stolen necklace and Johnny’s repeated use of forestry equipment all suggest an environmentalist and conservationist dimension to the film. Humanity enters the forest, exploits its resources, kills its animals and takes what doesn’t belong to it. Johnny, a creature literally born from the earth, responds with violence. Whether Nash intended this as an environmental allegory or simply incorporated these elements to reinforce Johnny’s connection with the natural world, I think the result is a surprisingly compelling story about nature fighting back.
But perhaps the most unsettling aspect of the film is that Johnny doesn’t appear to be motivated by any grand sense of ecological justice. Like the bear described in the closing conversation, he simply acts according to his nature. He doesn’t distinguish between those who have harmed the forest and those who are merely passing through it. His violence is indiscriminate, excessive and entirely indifferent to human suffering. In that respect, he is much closer to a natural predator than a conventional slasher villain.
And that’s what makes In a Violent Nature the perfect title for this movie