Warning: Major spoilers for Obsession (2026).

By now you should have seen Curry Barker’s Obsession. It’s a movie that shouldn’t be as scary as it is, but it is terrifying. And I don’t mean the directing choices, the sound design, or the strange reverse movements that Nikki does at one point. The real horror of Obsession is something much more disturbing.

If you think about it, our main protagonist is Bear, but the real victim is Nikki Freeman. Bear makes a wish on a ‘One-Wish Willow’ that Nikki would love him more than anyone else in the world. To be fair, he doesn’t expect the wish to work, but it does. After some awkward interactions, they form a relationship and Bear goes along for the ride, even though Nikki’s love for him only exists because he wished it into existence. However, we eventually discover that the Nikki who doesn’t love Bear more than anyone else in the world is a trapped prisoner somewhere inside wish-Nikki’s body, screaming to be released.

In this movie, Bear is the villain and Nikki is the victim. We should recognise this, and we should be pleased when Nikki does something strange and unpredictable that makes Bear fearful. Taken to its extreme, if Nikki somehow causes Bear’s death, she’ll be released from her prison. Still, we are frightened. So why are we so frightened for Bear? Perhaps the answer lies in existentialism, particularly the philosophy of Jean-Paul Sartre. Let me explain.

(Disclaimer: I wish to make it perfectly clear that I do not condone any of Bear’s behaviour in the movie. I do not argue that Bear deserves sympathy. I do not think that Bear’s suffering is any worse than Nikki’s. I simply explain - from an existentialist standpoint - why we might recognise the horror that Bear is experiencing).

L’être-pour-soi and L’être-en-soi

In his 1943 philosophical work Being and Nothingness, Jean-Paul Sartre distinguishes between two fundamental modes of being: l’être-pour-soi (being-for-itself) and l’être-en-soi (being-in-itself).

Being-for-itself describes conscious existence. Unlike an inanimate object, a conscious person is aware of themselves and their place in the world. They can make choices, imagine possibilities and determine what they want to become. For Sartre, human beings are not simply defined by what they are at any given moment, but by their freedom to choose what they might become.

Being-in-itself, by contrast, describes the existence of things that simply are. A rock, a table or a chair has no consciousness, no ambitions and no capacity to choose its own existence. It simply exists as what it is, without the possibility of becoming something else through its own decisions.

The moment Bear’s wish takes hold, Nikki’s freedom as a conscious being is effectively annihilated. Her authentic self, her ambitions and her autonomy are suppressed, reducing her to a hollow vessel manufactured entirely to validate Bear’s ego. “Wish Nikki” is not a person in any meaningful sense, but an object whose entire existence is dictated by Bear’s desire. She may have Nikki’s looks, voice and memories, but she is no longer the being-for-itself that Bear was interested in. Her consciousness has been subordinated to a single purpose: loving Bear.

Of course, Nikki has not literally become an inanimate object. Her real consciousness remains trapped inside her body, desperately trying to assert itself. This is perhaps the most horrifying aspect of her transformation. She retains an awareness of her own existence, but has lost the freedom to act upon it. What Bear truly wanted is now gone, and if we think about it, he never really got what he wished for, even if the One-Wish Willow manufacturer on the phone told him that he did.

Mauvaise foi

Bear is a victim of his own self-deception. Sartre argues that when a person denies their own freedom and responsibility, convincing themselves that they have no choice but to behave in a particular way, they act in bad faith (mauvaise foi). It is a form of self-deception that allows us to avoid the anxiety of making choices and accepting responsibility for their consequences.

Bear is an incredibly anxious character. He wants to express his feelings for Nikki, which is obvious from the opening scenes in the diner. We follow him from his phone call with Nikki to dropping her off at her house after drinks at the pub, and we see that he loses multiple opportunities to be honest with both himself and Nikki, even when she asks him outright whether he likes her. He chooses to act nonchalant and uninterested when, in fact, he is completely infatuated with her. He tells her that he likes her as a friend, rather than risking rejection by telling her the truth.

Instead of accepting the uncertainty that comes with expressing his feelings, he lets the One-Wish Willow override all future possibilities and dictate the outcome. The wish is a shortcut that allows Bear to enjoy the possible rewards of authenticity without ever having to confront the anxiety of being authentic. More importantly, it removes Nikki’s freedom to make her own choice. Bear would rather have guaranteed affection than risk discovering whether Nikki genuinely loves him.

Even when he experiences the horrors of his decision, he refuses to take accountability for the reality he has created. He calls the One-Wish Willow manufacturer and asks for his wish to be ‘altered’, he blames the witchcraft store for selling the One-Wish Willows, and he goes to his friend Ian to ask him to fix his mess. He is in denial that he caused all this. Bear wants the consequences of his actions reversed, but he desperately wants somebody else to take responsibility for reversing them.

We recognise that Bear repeatedly acts in bad faith, and shows a pattern of behaviour that suggests he will continue to do so. Even towards the end, when he considers ending his own life to free Nikki from her prison, he repeatedly recoils from the decision. His fear of death is understandable, and certainly not a moral failing in itself, but it reflects the wider tragedy of a man who has spent the entire film avoiding difficult choices. He has constructed a nightmare through his refusal to accept uncertainty, and now finds himself facing a decision with consequences far greater than the possibility of romantic rejection.

Le regard

In Jean-Paul Sartre’s play No Exit, Joseph Garcin declares that “hell is other people”. It is a statement often misunderstood as suggesting that other people are simply irritating or unpleasant. Sartre’s argument is more complicated, and concerns the power that other people have over our sense of self.

Sartre explores this through the concept of le regard (the look, or the gaze). When another person looks at us, we become aware that we exist not only as conscious individuals, but also as objects in somebody else’s consciousness. They can judge us, interpret our actions and form an understanding of who we are that we cannot entirely control. We may reject their judgement, but we cannot prevent them from making it. We are forced to confront an uncomfortable truth: other people have the freedom to define us in ways that may conflict with how we define ourselves.

In Obsession, Bear’s wish strips Nikki Freeman of her autonomy and replaces it with a ‘love’ that is singularly focused on Bear. Her gaze is unceasing, possessive and terrifying. Her actions are erratic and unpredictable. She makes him eat a sandwich containing his own dead cat. She threatens self-harm when he makes plans to see friends without her. She commits violent, brutal murder when he sneaks off to speak to Sarah.

We know that unless this wish is somehow broken, Nikki will continue to focus on Bear forever. He will endlessly be the subject of Nikki’s very specific and very critical gaze. He may never be able to take any action that does not somehow define him as a ‘bad boyfriend’. Nikki tearfully wails that she fears Bear doesn’t love her as much as she loves him, and now Bear is trapped within that perception. No matter how much affection he demonstrates, he can never satisfy the impossible expectations that his own wish has created.

There is a delicious irony here. Bear uses the One-Wish Willow to eliminate Nikki’s freedom, reducing her to an object that exists solely for his benefit. But in doing so, he creates someone whose gaze completely dominates his own existence. He wanted to control how Nikki felt about him, and instead finds himself controlled by how Nikki perceives him. He has traded the possibility of rejection for the certainty of being loved, only to discover that unconditional love can become an inescapable prison.

By his own actions, Bear is in the ‘hell’ posited by Sartre. We may not have any sympathy for him, but we recognise his hell for what it is.

Bear made his own hell

Perhaps this is why Obsession is so effective. We recognise that Nikki is the true victim, but we experience the film primarily through Bear’s perspective and we understand the horror from his point of view. We share his uncertainty, his helplessness and his growing realisation that he has lost control over his own existence. We are frightened for him not necessarily because we believe he deserves our sympathy, but because we recognise something fundamentally human in his predicament.

Sartre famously argued that we are condemned to be free. Freedom is not simply a privilege, but a burden, because every choice we make carries consequences for which we are responsible. Bear attempts to escape that burden by wishing away uncertainty, and in doing so destroys Nikki’s freedom and ultimately his own.

The real horror of Obsession is not simply that Nikki loves Bear too much. It is that Bear wanted to be loved without risking rejection, wanted a relationship without uncertainty, and wanted the rewards of his decisions without accepting responsibility for them. He wanted to escape the uncomfortable realities of being human.

And in trying to escape them, he created his own hell.