I love a good folk horror movie. But there’s something I’ve noticed about these movies: whenever a community worships nature, celebrates the solstice or invokes an ancient deity, there’s a reasonably good chance that somebody is going to end up being sacrificed. Paganism has a long history, but horror movies seem particularly determined to associate it with murder, sinister rituals and people dancing naked around bonfires. Admittedly, that last one isn’t necessarily inaccurate.
So why does paganism have such a terrible reputation in horror? And how much of what we see on screen has any basis in reality?
What is folk horror?
Folk horror is among the oldest, perhaps the oldest, subgenres of horror movie (see: Häxan), although its definition is surprisingly recent. The term was first used in a film context in 1970 by Rod Cooper to describe The Blood on Satan’s Claw, although it would be decades before it became widely established as a genre (https://www.videomaker.com/how-to/directing/film-history/everything-there-is-to-know-about-the-folk-horror-genre/). Wikipedia defines ‘folk horror’ as ‘a subgenre of horror film and horror fiction that uses elements of folklore to invoke fear and foreboding’, identifying rural settings, isolation, superstition, folk religion, paganism, sacrifice and the darker aspects of nature as recurring elements (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folk_horror).
In Adam Scovell’s book Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange, he proposes the ‘folk horror chain’, which contains four interconnected elements:
- Landscape, often rural, ancient or otherwise unsettling.
- Isolation, whether geographical, cultural or social.
- Skewed moral beliefs or systems within the isolated community.
- A horrifying happening or summoning, often involving violence or supernatural forces.
Often the protagonist is a naïve intruder in this location, such as Sergeant Neil Howie in The Wicker Man, or the group of Americans visiting the Hårga in Midsommar.
Many movies share DNA with folk horror, and their proximity to the folk horror chain can determine whether they’re widely considered part of the genre. The Texas Chain Saw Massacre is arguably folk horror, perhaps best described as Americana folk horror. It has a rural location and an isolated group with skewed morals, although that group is merely a small family. But then, the same applies to The VVitch. Similarly, Wake in Fright shares some folk horror DNA. It has a remote location, an insular community with its own unwritten rules that may seem strange to an outsider, and some deeply disturbing violence. Picnic at Hanging Rock feels like a folk horror as well with the panpipe soundtrack and strange trance-like atmosphere, but the supernatural forces are more implied and there’s hardly an isolated community or skewed moral beliefs.
Some of my favourite movies are folk horror. I’m a fan of the early Children of the Corn movies, and I have a special love for Midsommar. I really appreciate The Blood on Satan’s Claw, The Wicker Man, The Ritual and The VVitch, and have enjoyed Kill List and The Village. I like to think that my favourite movie of all time, Troll 2, is folk horror, although it’s probably more of a creature feature. Then again, it has an isolated community of vegetarian goblins, so perhaps it deserves a place in the genre after all.
What is occult horror?
More common than folk horror is occult horror. Occult horror films involve dark and secret supernatural practices, such as witchcraft, Satanism, demonology and sinister cultisms. There are many notable films in this genre, including Rosemary’s Baby, The Omen, Suspiria, Hereditary and A Dark Song, among others.
Occult horror and folk horror frequently overlap, but they aren’t quite the same thing. Occult horror is generally concerned with hidden supernatural knowledge, forbidden rituals and the consequences of meddling with forces beyond human understanding. Sometimes the victims become a victim to occult practices they shouldn’t be messing with, such as A Dark Song, Ouija, Talk to Me and The Craft. Most occult horror, however, involve a practitioner or demonic entity with strange and dangerous powers.
Folk horror, on the other hand, tends to draw its terror from landscape, isolation, tradition and communities whose beliefs differ from those of the outside world. An occult horror film might feature a secret society conducting a demonic ritual in a New York apartment, while a folk horror film might feature an entire village conducting a harvest ceremony in the English countryside. Both could involve people wearing robes and doing terrible things, but the source of the horror is slightly different.
Recent occult horror movies I particularly love include Shelby Oaks, Weapons, Bring Her Back, Longlegs, The Autopsy of Jane Doe and Hokum. I love a good demonic entity with big horns. I also love a good movie with a demon possession, but not one where a Christian priest saves the day - for example, I love Night of the Demons and all the Evil Dead films.
What is paganism?
Like ‘folk horror’, ‘paganism’ is a somewhat loaded definition. Depending on who you ask and when, paganism can refer to a wide variety of polytheistic and nature-oriented religious traditions, including religions practised before the spread of Christianity and modern movements that emerged or were revived during the twentieth century. Historically, Christians also used the term to describe religions outside Christianity, often dismissively.
Modern paganism is not one unified religion. It’s an umbrella term covering numerous traditions including Druidry, Heathenry, Hellenism, modern Celtic paganism and Wicca. Wicca is probably among the best-known modern pagan religions, but not all pagans are Wiccan, just as not all Christians are Catholic.
Modern pagans practise their spirituality in many different ways. Some honour particular gods and goddesses, while others focus on nature, seasonal cycles, ancestors or personal spiritual development. Practices might include celebrating the solstices and equinoxes, observing festivals such as Samhain and Beltane, setting up altars, making offerings, meditation, divination or conducting rituals outdoors. Some pagans belong to organised groups, while others practise independently. There is no universal pagan scripture, central religious authority or single set of beliefs that all pagans must follow.
For many contemporary pagans, reverence for nature is particularly important. The changing seasons, the cycles of life and death, and humanity’s relationship with the natural world can hold profound spiritual significance. A ritual might involve lighting candles, offering food or drink to a deity, or simply spending time outdoors. It’s generally rather less dramatic than what happens in Midsommar, and considerably less likely to involve somebody being killed for the sake of a strong harvest.
Despite growing public awareness of alternative spiritual traditions, paganism still suffers from misconceptions. In Christian societies, the word ‘pagan’ has historically carried negative associations with idolatry, superstition and moral corruption. But this doesn’t mean everybody regards paganism negatively. Modern pagan communities have become increasingly visible, and followers have grown in numbers. In fact, a 2014 Pew Research Centre study predicted that populations of faiths outside Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Hinduism and Buddhism would triple in size in North America, from 2.2 million (0.6% of the population) in 2010 to 6.6 million (1.5% of the population) in 2050, due largely to switching into other religions (such as Wicca and pagan religions) in the United States (https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2015/04/02/other-religions/).
One particularly persistent misconception is that paganism and Satanism are interchangeable. They aren’t.
Satan is a figure associated primarily with Abrahamic religious traditions, particularly Christianity and Islam. Most pagan religions do not recognise Satan as a deity. Satanism itself is also more complicated than its portrayal in horror movies. Some Satanist organisations, including the Church of Satan and The Satanic Temple, understand Satan primarily as a symbolic figure rather than a literal supernatural being. Other forms of Satanism are theistic. But none of this makes Satanism synonymous with paganism.
The confusion has deep historical roots. As Christianity spread through Europe, pre-Christian gods and religious practices were sometimes reinterpreted as demonic. The imagery of horned deities, for example, became entangled with Christian representations of the Devil, even though horned gods existed in religious traditions long before Christianity.
Paganism in horror movies
Usually when paganism is depicted in a horror movie, ceremonies and nature worship seem to involve human sacrifice. Whether it’s the burning wicker effigy in The Wicker Man, the gruesome midsummer celebrations in Midsommar, or the cult worshipping an ancient forest entity in The Ritual, the message is remarkably consistent: those cheerful people celebrating the harvest are probably planning to sacrifice you. But is there any historical basis for this association? Did pagans ever perform human sacrifice in reality? The short answer is yes, at least some did.
Human sacrifice is documented or strongly evidenced in several ancient societies, including some that would historically have been described as pagan (https://www.digitalmedievalist.com/opinionated-celtic-faqs/human-sacrifice/). Classical writers such as Julius Caesar described human sacrifice among the Gauls, including accounts of large structures containing victims who were burned alive (which would sound familiar to anybody who has seen The Wicker Man). However, Caesar was writing about peoples he was also trying to conquer. His accounts cannot be treated as entirely impartial historical evidence, and historians have questioned the accuracy and motivations behind some of his descriptions. In particular, the famous image of people being burned inside enormous wicker structures is known primarily from classical literary accounts, rather than direct archaeological confirmation.
There is nevertheless archaeological evidence suggesting that ritual human killing occurred in parts of ancient Europe. The preserved remains of some Iron Age bog bodies, including Lindow Man in Britain and Tollund Man in Denmark, have prompted considerable scholarly discussion about possible ritual sacrifice. Their unusual deaths and deposition in wetlands suggest that some may have been killed for ceremonial purposes, although the interpretation of individual cases remains contested.
Human sacrifice was also practised in some other ancient societies. But it would be a mistake to assume that sacrifice was a defining feature of paganism generally. Nor was religiously-justified violence exclusive to pagan societies. The history of Christianity includes persecution, executions for heresy and religiously-motivated warfare. These practices were not necessarily human sacrifice in the ritual sense, but they demonstrate that religious belief can be used to justify violence across many different traditions. Just watch The Witchfinder General and The Crucible.
Why does horror keep returning to pagan sacrifice?
Perhaps pagan imagery provides filmmakers with an extraordinarily effective visual language. Ancient stones, dense forests, animal masks, bonfires, harvest festivals and strange ceremonial costumes are all evocative. They suggest something old, mysterious and potentially beyond modern understanding, and perhaps a little dangerous.
Another reason might be that folk horror frequently relies on the fear of the unfamiliar. The protagonist enters a community whose traditions are different from their own, and gradually discovers that those traditions conceal something terrible. The religious practices aren’t necessarily frightening in themselves, but the outsider’s inability to understand them creates uncertainty. That uncertainty is then transformed into horror when the community reveals what it is prepared to do in the name of its beliefs.
The Wicker Man is particularly interesting because it complicates this dynamic. Sergeant Howie is a devout Christian whose rigid attitudes towards sexuality and morality frequently clash with the islanders’ more permissive pagan customs. The film doesn’t simply present Christianity as good and paganism as evil. Nevertheless, the islanders ultimately commit murder in the name of their religion, reinforcing the association between paganism and ritual violence.
Midsommar takes a similar approach but adds another layer of psychological manipulation. The Hårga initially appear welcoming, affectionate and deeply connected to nature. Their community offers Dani a sense of belonging that she has struggled to find elsewhere. The horror comes from discovering that this apparent harmony depends upon conformity, coercion and ritual killing. The film is not really demonstrating that nature worship is dangerous; it is exploring how an apparently loving community can normalise appalling behaviour.
I also wonder whether some of this might also be a lingering influence of the ‘Satanic Panic’, the moral panic of the 1980s and 1990s that saw widespread fears about Satanic cults, ritual abuse and occult practices, often with little or no credible evidence. Although the panic itself has largely subsided, some of the attitudes that fuelled it have never entirely disappeared. There will always be people with strongly held religious beliefs who regard anything resembling paganism, witchcraft or occult practices as inherently satanic, regardless of what those traditions actually involve. When audiences have been conditioned to find these things frightening, it’s hardly surprising that filmmakers keep returning to them.
So, should horror leave the pagans alone?
Absolutely not. I love pagan folk horror, and I certainly don’t want filmmakers to stop making it. Pagan traditions, mythology and folklore provide an enormous wealth of material for imaginative storytelling, and horror would be poorer without them.
But I do think it’s worth recognising how frequently the genre relies upon the same assumptions. Paganism becomes shorthand for something primitive, sinister or morally corrupt, while nature worship becomes a warning that human sacrifice is probably just around the corner. The repetition of these tropes can reinforce misconceptions about religious traditions that many people already know very little about.
I’d love to see more horror films drawing upon pagan mythology without automatically turning pagan worshippers into murderous cultists. There is plenty of terror to be found in ancient folklore, supernatural entities, sacred landscapes and the mysteries of the natural world without suggesting that the people who honour those traditions are inherently dangerous. Until then, I’ll continue enjoying my folk horror movies while occasionally reminding myself that most modern pagans are considerably more interested in celebrating the solstice than sacrificing the tourists.