I like to think that I don’t get scared very easily. A well-executed jump scare will get me, and occasionally a movie will make me feel genuinely uncomfortable. But have I, the self-proclaimed horror enthusiast, ever reached my limit with horror? I have. And I’ll get to that. But first, I want to talk about Australia’s long and rather extraordinary history of banning horror movies.

Horror has always been a controversial genre. For as long as filmmakers have been trying to frighten audiences, there have been people arguing that certain films are too frightening, too violent, too depraved or simply too offensive to be shown. Australia has a particularly interesting history in this regard, having once banned an entire genre of cinema for two decades. Over the years, government censors, classification review boards and even judges have been involved in deciding what Australians should and shouldn’t be allowed to watch.

Classification in Australia today

In Australia, the Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) Act 1995 (Cth) establishes the framework for classifying publications, films and computer games. The ratings for films are G through to R18+. But there’s another classification that filmmakers would rather avoid: Refused Classification (RC). Films that receive this classification cannot generally be legally sold, hired, advertised or publicly exhibited in Australia, and its importation and exportation are also subject to restrictions (++https://www.classification.gov.au/for-industry/import-or-export-objectionable-goods++).

The National Classification Scheme is a cooperative arrangement between the Commonwealth and the states and territories. The Australian Classification Board is responsible for classifying films, while the states and territories have their own legislation governing how those classifications are enforced. This means that the legal consequences of a classification can vary between jurisdictions. Where I live, in the ACT, there are substantial penalties for selling or publicly exhibiting RC films under the Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) (Enforcement) Act 1995 (ACT), division 2.2.

The distinction between classification and censorship is important. In principle, classification is supposed to help people make informed choices about what they watch, while restricting certain material to adults. Censorship goes a step further by preventing people from accessing certain material. Australia’s approach has gradually shifted away from outright censorship, but the RC category demonstrates that there are still limits to what adults are permitted to watch.

Of course, these laws didn’t appear out of nowhere. Australia’s history of film censorship stretches back well before the current classification system, to a time when government officials could decide that an entire category of entertainment was simply unsuitable for the Australian public. And in 1948, that’s exactly what happened.

The 1948 horror ban in Australia

I wasn’t around at the time, but in 1948 the Chief Commonwealth Film Censor, Mr J. O. Alexander, decided that horror films would be banned in Australia (++https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/22555510++). The ban was introduced on 22 April 1948 and remained in place, at least as a general policy, for the next 20 years.

Alexander’s reasoning is quite extraordinary by today’s standards. He considered horror films to have no meaningful cultural or entertainment value, and believed that the people who enjoyed them were precisely the sort of people who shouldn’t be encouraged to watch them. He even suggested that horror films posed a potential danger to women in delicate health. Apparently, a Frankenstein movie was considered a genuine public health concern.

The National Archives of Australia has an excellent article about the ban (++https://www.naa.gov.au/blog/exit-ghouls++), which explains that horror films had already attracted complaints from church groups and parents’ associations during the 1930s. By 1948, the genre was experiencing something of a slump anyway, with Universal’s classic monsters increasingly becoming objects of parody. Banning horror films was therefore a relatively easy way for the government to appease those concerned about the moral influence of cinema.

During those 20 years, horror began to come back into fashion internationally, perhaps thanks in large part to Alfred Hitchcock and Psycho (1960). Australians, however, would have had considerable difficulty seeing films such as House of Wax (1953), Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954), Diabolique (1955), House on Haunted Hill (1959), Eyes Without a Face (1960), The Birds (1963) and The Haunting (1963), among other classics. Many of these films would barely raise an eyebrow today, let alone inspire calls for censorship.

The ban wasn’t quite as absolute as it sounds. Some horror films managed to reach Australian audiences during the 1960s, including Psycho itself, and there were exceptions for film festivals (++https://aso.gov.au/chronology/1940s/++).

The ban was finally lifted in 1968, a year that also saw an important High Court decision, Crowe v Graham. The case concerned the interpretation of obscenity and indecency laws, rather than horror films specifically, but it formed part of a broader change in Australian attitudes towards censorship. The following decade would see a gradual shift towards classifying films according to their content rather than simply deciding whether the public should be permitted to see them (++https://www.alrc.gov.au/publication/national-classification-scheme-review-dp-77/2-the-current-classification-scheme/history-of-censorship-and-classification/++).

Shortly after the ban was lifted, Australia itself began producing movies that are now considered classics of Australian horror. Wake in Fright (1971) might not have much in the way of blood or killer maniacs, but it’s certainly an unsettling and disturbing film about a man’s rapid descent into depravity in the rough Australian outback. Then there was Long Weekend (1978), about a bickering couple who go camping and disrespect nature, so nature decides to disrespect them right back.

In 1975, we also had Picnic at Hanging Rock, based on the novel by Joan Lindsay. It isn’t conventional horror, but it’s frequently described as eerie and haunting, so how could it not be? These films demonstrated that Australian filmmakers didn’t need vampires, werewolves or haunted castles to frighten audiences. Our vast landscapes, isolation, uncomfortable social environments and occasionally hostile wildlife were more than capable of doing the job.

And although the general ban on horror had ended, that certainly didn’t mean Australian censors had developed an appetite for the more extreme films that were beginning to emerge overseas.

The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974)

One of the most famous horror films to encounter Australian censorship was Tobe Hooper’s The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974). The film was first refused registration in 1975, and even an edited version failed to satisfy the censors. It was rejected again in 1981 before finally receiving an R-rating in January 1984, allowing it to be released in Australian cinemas (++https://www.refused-classification.com/censorship/film-1/tobe-hooper/#texas-chainsaw-massacre++).

What makes The Texas Chain Saw Massacre particularly interesting is how much of its horror is suggested rather than explicitly shown. Despite its reputation as one of the bloodiest films ever made, there’s surprisingly little graphic violence on screen. Hooper relies heavily on editing, sound and the audience’s imagination to create the impression that they are witnessing something truly horrific.

The Australian release was even promoted on the basis that it had previously been banned, turning the film’s censorship history into a selling point. There’s something wonderfully ironic about that. The very thing intended to discourage audiences from seeing the movie had made it even more appealing. I know this certainly would have drawn me in.

Cannibal Holocaust (1980)

If The Texas Chain Saw Massacre pushed the boundaries of what audiences could tolerate, Ruggero Deodato’s Cannibal Holocaust (1980) took things considerably further. It remains one of the most notorious horror films ever made.

The movie follows an anthropologist who travels into the Amazon rainforest to investigate the disappearance of a documentary film crew. He eventually discovers their footage, which reveals that the supposedly civilised filmmakers were responsible for horrific acts of cruelty and exploitation. The film presents much of this material as recovered footage, decades before The Blair Witch Project popularised the found-footage format.

The film’s reputation was so extreme that Deodato faced legal proceedings in Italy amid allegations that some of the deaths depicted on screen were real. The human deaths were staged, but the film’s animal cruelty was not. Several animals were genuinely killed during production, something that remains deeply controversial and, in my view, entirely indefensible.

Australia refused registration to Cannibal Holocaust in 1983. Even a shortened version was rejected, and the film remained prohibited for more than two decades. Imported copies were seized by Customs, and a planned screening at the Melbourne Underground Film Festival in 2001 was among several screenings abandoned because of censorship concerns. In October 2005, the film was finally granted an R18+ classification, with an uncut DVD released in Australia in April 2006 (++https://www.refused-classification.com/censorship/film-1/ruggero-deodato/#cannibal-holocaust++).

There is an argument that Cannibal Holocaust is a genuinely important film. Beneath its sensationalism, it attempts to criticise exploitation, sensationalist journalism and the hypocrisy of supposedly civilised societies. The problem, of course, is that its filmmakers committed actual acts of cruelty while making a film that supposedly condemns cruelty and exploitation. It’s a difficult film to defend, but it also raises an important distinction between simulated violence and genuine harm, even if the harm is done to animals.

Wolf Creek (2005)

Australian horror had its own censorship controversy in 2005 with the release of Greg McLean’s Wolf Creek. Unlike the other films discussed here, however, its temporary ban had nothing to do with the usual concerns about violence, sex or public morality.

Wolf Creek follows three backpackers travelling through the Australian outback who encounter Mick Taylor, a seemingly friendly local who turns out to be a sadistic serial killer. The film draws inspiration from several real Australian crimes, including the backpacker murders committed by Ivan Milat and the murder of British tourist Peter Falconio.

At the time of the film’s release, Bradley John Murdoch was on trial in the Northern Territory for Falconio’s murder. Chief Justice Brian Martin prevented the film from being screened in the Territory because of concerns that it could prejudice Murdoch’s right to a fair trial. The restriction was lifted following Murdoch’s conviction in December 2005, and the film subsequently screened in the Territory (++https://www.abc.net.au/news/2005-12-15/wolf-creek-ban-puzzles-director/762116++).

This is a particularly interesting example because it demonstrates that not every restriction on a horror film is necessarily censorship in the traditional sense.

As for the film itself, Wolf Creek is one of the defining examples of modern Australian horror. John Jarratt’s portrayal of Mick Taylor is terrifying precisely because he initially appears so ordinary. 

It also makes excellent use of the Australian landscape. The vastness of the outback, normally celebrated for its beauty and freedom, becomes a place of complete isolation and helplessness. There’s nowhere to run, nobody to call and very little hope of rescue. It’s the sort of horror that feels uniquely Australian, and its success helped demonstrate that Australian filmmakers could produce internationally recognised horror without relying on Hollywood conventions.

A Serbian Film (2010)

And now we come to the film I mentioned at the beginning of this article. The one that managed to push even my tolerance for horror beyond its limits.

A Serbian Film (2010), directed by Srđan Spasojević, follows a retired pornographic actor who accepts a lucrative offer to appear in one final production. What initially appears to be an opportunity to secure his family’s financial future descends into a nightmare involving extreme sexual violence, exploitation, incest and child abuse. It’s a film seemingly designed to shock its audience as much as humanly possible, and it certainly succeeds in doing that.

The filmmakers have defended the movie as a political allegory about exploitation and the suffering of the Serbian people. There may well be something to that interpretation, but whether the film’s political message justifies its extraordinarily graphic content is another question entirely.

The film had a particularly troubled history with Australian censors. The original version was refused classification in November 2010, and a subsequent edited version was also rejected. After further cuts, removing almost four minutes of footage, the Classification Board finally granted the film an R18+ rating in April 2011.

That wasn’t the end of the story. The South Australian government took action to prohibit the film’s distribution in that state, and the Commonwealth Minister for Justice subsequently requested a review of its national classification. In September 2011, the Classification Review Board unanimously overturned the R18+ rating and refused classification. The film remains banned in Australia (++https://www.refused-classification.com/censorship/film-1/a-serbian-film/++).

This is where my usual opposition to censorship becomes a little more complicated.

I have the displeasure of saying that I’ve seen this film. I’ve watched quite a few horror movies that have been banned at some point in Australia, including all the others I’ve discussed in this article. Normally, I’m firmly on the side of allowing adults to make their own decisions about what they watch. But A Serbian Film is the one film where I find myself agreeing with the censors.

I simply cannot understand how a film like this can be considered entertaining, and I believe films should, in some way, provide entertainment. That doesn’t necessarily mean they need to be enjoyable. Horror can be uncomfortable, confronting, depressing or deeply upsetting, and still be worthwhile. Some of my favourite horror films are anything but pleasant experiences. But I struggle to find any value in A Serbian Film, and whatever political message it was trying to communicate was completely overwhelmed by its determination to shock.

I also understand the appeal of forbidden cinema. There’s something exciting about watching a movie that has been deemed too disturbing for public consumption, almost as though you’re discovering something you’re not supposed to see. I’ve certainly felt that thrill before. But having watched A Serbian Film, I genuinely don’t think anyone is meant to see this.

And yet, I recognise the contradiction in my position. If I believe adults should be free to decide what they watch, why should my personal disgust with one particular film justify denying that choice to everyone else? Just because I cannot find any artistic or entertainment value in a film doesn’t necessarily mean nobody else can. It’s an uncomfortable question, and one I don’t have a particularly satisfying answer to.

Horror, morality and censorship

Looking back over Australia’s history of horror censorship, it’s remarkable how much our standards have changed. In 1948, government officials believed that horror films had no cultural value and that the people who enjoyed them were somehow morally suspect. Today, horror is one of cinema’s most commercially successful and creatively diverse genres, with films regularly exploring subjects such as grief, trauma, religion, sexuality and social inequality.

Movies that were once considered too disturbing for Australian audiences are now celebrated as classics. The Texas Chain Saw Massacre is studied for its filmmaking techniques, Psycho is regarded as a masterpiece, and even Cannibal Holocaust, despite its very real ethical problems, has an established place in the history of horror cinema. What was once considered dangerous or obscene can eventually become culturally significant.

This raises an obvious problem with censorship: who gets to decide what constitutes acceptable entertainment? There’s also a difference between finding something offensive and believing it should be prohibited. I can watch a film and think it’s disgusting, exploitative or completely devoid of artistic merit without necessarily believing the government should prevent other adults from seeing it.

As for me, I’ll continue watching horror movies, especially those with a particularly notorious reputation. I enjoy being frightened, disturbed and challenged, and I don’t want filmmakers to stop pushing boundaries. But I’ve also learned that I have boundaries of my own. The difference is that I can choose never to watch it again. Whether that means nobody else should be allowed to watch it is a much harder question.